Diplomacy & Crisis News

En France comme à l'étranger, la connivence des pouvoirs politiques avec de puissants patrons de presse attire régulièrement l'attention sur le contrôle des médias. Quelques groupes industriels possèdent la plupart des maisons d'édition et contrôlent une grande partie du contenu et de la distribution (...) / Culture, Économie, Idées, Industrie culturelle, Livre, Politique - 2007/10

This article is the English version of : Chantal Delsol, « Le crépuscule de l’universel », published in Politique étrangère, Vol. 84, Issue 1, 2019.

During the two centuries following the French Revolution, Western culture has claimed its status as upholder of universal values to justify its spread around the world. Our conquests were disguised as missions, in keeping with a long tradition – from Pericles bringing democracy to subject cities, through to Christians leading crusades in the name of Truth. A faith in human rights was the new gospel preached by its disciples. And the message was getting through. After Peter the Great’s Westernization of Russia by force, Japan and Turkey followed suit. Over two centuries, foreign cultures all became Westernized, more or less of their own will, and often laying claim to our principles and using our terminology.

All regimes, even autocratic ones, were keen to call themselves “democratic.” Western leaders, who toured the world to lecture on human rights, were frequently received in host countries with protestations of the countries’ excellent democratic credentials. The general feeling that there was some virtue attached to Western culture came from the idea of progress. Everyone wanted to be “modern.” History was even reinterpreted. Perhaps more out of diplomacy than conviction, the Chinese went so far as to claim around the time of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights that they had played a role in starting the eighteenth-century Enlightenment. 

All this was true until the turn of the twenty-first century. For almost twenty years now, the Western message has been received differently. And on all continents: in China and many of its neighbors, in the majority of Islamic countries, and in Russia. What is new is that for the first time, we are confronted by foreign cultures that openly oppose our model, reject it with reasons, and justify a different type of society from ours. In other words, they dismiss the universality of the principles we sought to bring to the world and possibly see them as the results of an ideology. This rejection is new, not in its expression, but rather in its scale. It overturns the understanding of universalism we thought we upheld. It changes the geopolitical order. The ideological nature of the break is beyond all doubt: it is our individualism that is in question, and everything that comes with it.

Several points need to be made in order to gain a better understanding of this unprecedented situation. The cultural centers in question tend to put forward similar arguments to delegitimize the West. They question our role as a culture of emancipation and freedom; and their role, they say, is to defend communities, both small and large. One might say that in the face of the individualist West a huge holistic front has been opened up. Certainly, the bipolar world of the Cold War, which left a unipolar world after the fall of the Berlin Wall, has now become multipolar. But rather than seeing here a “clash of civilizations,” one should first attempt to ascertain the extent of the anti-Western movement that is being expressed everywhere and giving way to a new era. […]

Read the rest of the article here.

>>> More articles of Politique étrangère are available for reading
on Cairn International <<<

Targeted, sharp action to reverse the coup is urgently needed.

Democracies have to learn how to manage some people’s innate fears of change.

Even the best-intentioned cryptocurrencies can become scams.

Although a ceasefire in Eastern Ukraine has led to a significant decrease in civilian casualties, the overall situation remains fragile unless progress is made on the security and political fronts, the UN’s political affairs chief told the Security Council on Thursday. 

Amidst some positive news from the World Health Organization (WHO) that both COVID-19 deaths and new cases have recently been on the wane, there are “three major threats” to the UN-led international equitable vaccine initiative, COVAX, that require urgent attention. 

Ageism has colored the response to COVID-19 and is setting everyone up for a more difficult economic recovery.

The U.S. president has already halted some arms sales to the Gulf. How he handles the rest will be a bellwether for progressives’ sway over his foreign policy.

Oui, heureuse province, aujourd'hui comme hier, Bourgogne... nom sans faille, a écrit l'un de ses fils, le romancier Raymond Dumay – tout rond, qui semble-rouler comme un tonneau plein... C'est encore un de nos paradis gourmands. Lentement et sûrement s'est formée une tradition et, les uns après (...) / France, Agriculture, Alimentation, Identité culturelle - 1955/01

Le repas gastronomique des Français est désormais inscrit sur la liste du patrimoine culturel immatériel de l'humanité. Dans le contexte actuel, cette muséification a quelque chose de grotesque, voire d'indécent. / France, Agroalimentaire, Alimentation, Identité culturelle, Loisirs, Société - (...) / France, Agroalimentaire, Alimentation, Identité culturelle, Loisirs, Société - 2011/01

UN independent human rights experts appealed on Thursday for authorities in Egypt to remove two activists from a “terrorist” list and to stop systemic use of terrorism powers. 

The African Continental Free Trade Area is already running up against the hard realities of the continent’s endemic trade barriers.

Futur « centre du monde », ou future poudrière ? Le développement de l'Extrême-Orient fascine, suscite des commentaires hyperboliques dont la conférence de la Coopération économique de l'Asie-Pacifique (CEAP) réunie à Seattle à la fin de novembre a, une fois encore, été l'occasion. A long terme pourtant, (...) / Asie, Démographie, Ville, Pauvreté, Société, Économie, Environnement - 1993/12

The administration is moving quickly to reassert U.S. leadership but needs Beijing’s support for major initiatives.

The new president wants his strategy to seem reassuring. It’s anything but.

The 1994 Ethiopian Constitution celebrated self-determination, but it laid the groundwork for today’s violence. Devolution could offer a way out.

Myanmar’s generals have proven they can survive sanctions. But sustained public pressure may be harder to endure.

Women are extremely under-represented in science, but a UN research centre in The Netherlands is trying to address the gender imbalance, by raising awareness of the leading role that women researchers play in tackling global problems, such as the COVID-19 pandemic.

Led by student activists, the new civil-disobedience movement draws on the experience of older generations—but its methods and demands are a radical break with the past.